Agile Certification – Who To Certify?

Uncle Bob recently blasted out a posterous blog post about a “Certification Worth Having.”

Haven’t we heard a ton recently about Scrum certification and Agile certification in general?

As many Agile organizations roll out certifications (Scrum Alliance, Agile Alliance, Scrum.org, et.al.) a person has to wonder,

“What are the real criteria for giving an individual a certificate?”

As we posted earlier on a satire about Agile Manager award (and the one here), we just made one up!

Uncle Bob tells us that in order to have a (good) certification you must:

  • Work for the certification
  • It must take years
  • It should cost a boat-load
  • Not all can complete it

We would say that this doesn’t prove anything either! How many college graduates come out of college with useless degrees? How many certification programs have members that still can’t manage themselves nevertheless manage a team?

Let’s get to the core of the issue:

“What is the real best way of validating a certification?”

Is there even one? Does having certification just breed elitism after all?

We want to know. Seriously. Because we want to make our own Agile Scout certification that shows that people are really Agile or not. Duh (Satire folks)…

Who knows. Please do tell.

[HT: UncleBob]

5 Responses to “Agile Certification – Who To Certify?”

  1. Derek Huether
    November 23, 2010 at 3:11 pm #

    What are the real criteria for giving an individual a certificate?

    My personal belief is in the Dreyfus model of skill acquisition, a model of how students acquire skills through formal instruction and practicing.

    I strongly recommend readers of this post to go read Dennis Stevens’ blog post Certification, the Dreyfus Model, and Tilting at Windmills. I couldn’t help but comment on that blog post as well.

    This question will never be answered to the satisfaction of everyone. But, I do enjoy the discussion.

    • ScoutMaster
      November 23, 2010 at 3:59 pm #

      Thanks for this link! This really helps. So far Dennis has provided some pretty good material for the community. Thanks for pointing this out!

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Tweets that mention Agile Certification – Who To Certify? | Agile Scout -- Topsy.com - November 23, 2010

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by Suresh R Iyer, Agile Scout. Agile Scout said: Agile Certification – Who To Certify? http://goo.gl/fb/L0zr2 #agile #pmot [...]

  2. BAM! – PMI Agile Certification is Here | Agile Scout - April 21, 2011

    [...] It’s here. The waiting and wondering is over. PMI is launching an Agile certification. So what does this mean for an [...]

  3. The über ScrumMaster | Agile Scout - May 23, 2011

    [...] have a new Agile Certification course that I’ve been working through in my head: The über ScrumMaster [...]

Leave a Reply